Do you have an opinion? Debate Battle 1: Wikileaks

[sleevelesssky]

Do you have an opinion? [Pun intended]

Debaters Alert!


ReMag is currently recruiting volunteers to partake in the first ever Debate Battle, a special monthly section allocated in ReMag to accommodate and feature the diverse opinions of Recommers over a variety of current issues.

We are looking for 5 ReCommers to put forward their arguments regarding the chosen topic. Two will be supporting the issue, two will be opposing, and one will suggest a neutral opinion – be it the middle path between the two extremes, a conciliatory point of view, or an alternative perspective.

Opinions will be limited to an approximate 200 to 400 words.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Debate Battle 1: Is Wikileaks justified for the greater good?


Wikileaks, arguably the most famous (or infamous) whistle-blower website ever in history, has stirred up a storm of controversy by leaking confidential information of governments and corporations all over the world. While most countries have condemned the irresponsible actions of Wikileaks, a significant number of people, as well as many journalistic institutions, have chosen to defend Wikileaks on the basis of freedom of speech and information. However, is Wikileaks justified for the greater good - the greater good of all?

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

ReCommers who are interested to argue about the chosen topic can indicate their preference by leaving a comment HERE: Signing-up deadline is 12 am, Tuesday, 11 Jan 2011. Selected debaters will be notified by 10 pm, Thursday, 13 Jan 2011. [DEADLINE EXTENDED]

ReMag reserves the right to make final decision in terms of debater selection, in the case of excess participants.

[unsolvedcryptex]

While most countries have condemned the irresponsible actions of Wikileaks, a significant number of people, as well as many journalistic institutions, have chosen to defend Wikileaks on the basis of freedom of speech and information.

I doubt so that many journalistic institutions think that way. Read an article on New York Times on why, even journalists do not want to stand up to speak for Assange. Julian has brought journalism to a new dimension, and is heavily criticized by journalist for that reason.

Anyway, looking forward to it. :)

[Alexis Ma]

This seems quite my niche. Sign me up.

[sleevelesssky]

Two will be supporting the issue, two will be opposing, and one will suggest a neutral opinion – be it the middle path between the two extremes, a conciliatory point of view, or an alternative perspective.

Please indicate your preference. Thanks.

[Glassylicious]

Bump. We need more volunteers please. =)

[acgerlok7]

I doubt so that many journalistic institutions think that way. Read an article on New York Times on why, even journalists do not want to stand up to speak for Assange. Julian has brought journalism to a new dimension, and is heavily criticized by journalist for that reason.

Anyway, looking forward to it. :)

*post removed*

Bump. We need more volunteers please. =)

i've just volunteered myself.xD by replying to unsolvedryptex's point of view and i am standing out as an oppsoing side

[Young]

Acgerlok7, we appreciate your enthusiasm. :) However, do bear in mind this thread only serves as a sign-up thread. Once the selection of the participants is completed, you will be notified and subsequently, be invited to a private thread to debate in a more structured format.

That being said, thank you for expressing your interest. :)

[sleevelesssky]

Check your inbox, acgerlok7. :wink

Bump bump.

Once again I would like to remind that this is only a sign-up thread.

[unsolvedcryptex]

I am not part of this debate, and have not sign up. I am merely pointing out that WikiLeaks may not be regarded as part of journalism.

I did not indicate that I am in either side of the debate.

[Nicholasng925]

I am not part of this debate, and have not sign up. I am merely pointing out that WikiLeaks may not be regarded as part of journalism.

I did not indicate that I am in either side of the debate.

With your very short statement previously, you initiated acgerlok7 to oppose your idea with a very long post. Haha! xD It's a good thing though! :laugh

[louis]

Count me in. I am supporting the topic :)

[Glassylicious]

Bumping for more publicity.

[sleevelesssky]

Bump bump!

[eve88]

Oh... okay, if you're stil looking for ppl... and after my .... year's disappearance from here, i can pen something down.

Put me whatever side left over, (with neutral what i least prefer; and if im taking that stance id probably like the other responses first)

goodluck.

[slappyfin3]

Sorry, I'm not in the capacity to debate at the moment and I have formed a very neutral/apathetic opinion towards wikileaks so I wouldn't be able to contribute to a good debate. I'd love to read what you guys will argue though, perhaps it will enlighten me ^^

All the best!!

BUMP

[Chelsea]

count me in. this sound fun. I want to be on the neutral side.

[acgerlok7]

I'm on the supporting side.

[kykoay]

I am interested in arguing from the perspective of a centrist. I know that this is a sign up thread, but what other information should I post up here?

[Glassylicious]

I am interested in arguing from the perspective of a centrist. I know that this is a sign up thread, but what other information should I post up here?

Nothing else. =)

[sleevelesssky]

Bump!

Glad to see so many responses :)

[sleevelesssky]

Voting closed.

Successful applicants will be informed by Wednesday.

[eve88]

Voting? i wasnt aware we were voting.

in that case...

I vote the FSM.

[sleevelesssky]

I mean sign-up period closed. XD

[JasmineAnuar]

Count me in.
I'm on the nuetral side.
It's not too late to sign up,is it?

[frankchong]

http://www.asiasentinel.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=2931&Itemid=178

[bekann]

Count me in.
I'm on the nuetral side.
It's not too late to sign up,is it?

I think it already is too late. You can always sign up for next month though! :)